logo

Forensic Accounting
Brand Protection
Computer Forensics
Corporate Investigation

spacer
Search

The Kessler Report
THE KESSLER REPORT Continued
A Publication of Michael G. Kessler and Associates, Ltd.
Archive           Home
FraudBusters® Edition
Volume 1

Number 1

Tech Talk: Covert Product Marketing
What You Can't See Might Help You
      If you want to establish a product as your own, you put your mark on it: a signature, a label, a logo. Years ago, village craftspeople had no need of marks-the product itself would speak for the person who made it. Customers could tell who had produced the work from the way a shirt was cut, for example, or how a shoe was sewn. But as the village developed into the town and then the city, the marketplace expanded. Soon, producers could no longer be distinguished based on their work alone, and the trademark was born.
      Trademarks are how we represent the bond between a producer and a product. What counterfeiting does is weaken this bond. It often leaves manufacturers feeling powerless, because they can no longer rely on their name to represent the work they have produced.
      But now, instead of using overt markings such as labels, which can be counterfeited, manufacturers can mark their products covertly. One of the companies at the forefront of covert marking systems is Nocopi Technologies, based in Wayne, Pennsylvania. Nocopi offers businesses a variety of ways in which to discreetly mark products to guarantee authenticity. A clothing designer, for example, could include Nocopi in the production process, weaving a reactive thread into each garment or label. Determining whether an item was legitimate or not would then simply be a matter of testing the garment for that thread. Product quality would not be affected, but product authenticity would be secure.
      Nocopi can also print reactive invisible inks on paper, plastic, cardboard,
a simple test kit, helping businesses determine where diverted product entered the channels of distribution. Nocopi also has color changing inks, and Rub and Reveal papers, to meet other security protection needs.
      Another reputable company that offers covert surface marking is Biocode. They have developed over 30 marker-antibody pairs and they can be used in numerous combinations to mark liquid, solids, powder or granulated substances. Biocoding technology is still new, and the companies behind it see no end to the applications possible.
      The Tracer Detection Technology Corporation, based in Syosset, New York, also brings cutting-edge technology to the aid of corporate clients and law enforcement officials. Tracer is an advanced stage R&D company exploring the use of perfluorocarbon tracers (PFTs) as part of a chemical vapor tag system. Using PFTs is like using bloodhounds, except that the chemicals being hunted are present in levels as low as parts per trillion, which no bloodhound could detect (instead of dogs, Tracer uses gas chromatography equipment). The people, vehicles and rooms that were in close proximity to the object can also be located, as they will have trace amounts of the PFTs on them for a fixed length of time. Each Tracer system will be designed to meet the needs of the situation.
      Computer technology and high-resolution printing systems made counterfeiting and diversion much easier crimes to commit. The new wave of covert product marking technologies is expected to tip the balance in favor of concerned businesses once again.

New Law Helps Fight Counterfeits

      On July 2nd, President Clinton signed the Anti-counterfeiting Consumer Protection Act of 1996, S. 1136 (Public Law 104-153). This law, which had the International Anti-Counterfeiting Coalition behind it, was drafted to make counterfeiting a more heavily penalized crime.
      Under the new law, trafficking in counterfeit goods will be a RICO (Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations) Act, which results in increased jail time, higher fines, and
asset forfeiture. According to Senator Hatch, who co-sponsored the Act in the Senate, the bill "adds teeth to existing statutes by providing for further civil remedies, including civil fines pegged to the value of genuine goods, and statutory awards of up to $1 million per mark."
      Federal and local law enforcement traditionally would not get too involved in anti-counterfeiting operations because the weak penalties didn't justify the time and effort of the officers involved-other crimes were given priority. With S. 1136, that is expected to change. John Bliss, president of the IACC, states, "This is the most significant update to federal anticounterfeiting law in over a decade. We applaud Congress for getting tough on pirates both in the U.S. and abroad."

No Party for Third-Party Suppliers

      Did you know that if a company knowingly provides raw materials for counterfeiting, it may be held liable, even if it doesn't directly engage in counterfeit production? This past March, Judge Laughlin E. Waters of the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, ruled that Mohammed Abdallah and his company, General Audio Video Cassettes, had knowingly assisted counterfeiters nationwide by providing them with the audio cassettes needed to make unauthorized copies. Judge Waters granted A&M Records and 25 other Recording Industry Association of America member companies a landmark $7 million judgment.
      The case is noteworthy not only because of the record-breaking settlement, but also because there was no evidence that Abdallah or his business were involved in the actual production of illegitimate copies. They merely sold the tapes to the counterfeiting operations. Other businesses interested in going after third-party suppliers may want to establish this case as a precedent.


GUARANTEE OF DISCRETION
In addition to cost effective, thorough investigative services, the clients of Michael G. Kessler & Associates are assured the highest levels of discretion and sensitivity to individual situations. We never sell or rent client lists, or in any way reveal the details of our investigations.

4


Copyright © Michael G. Kessler & Associates, Ltd. 1996. All rights reserved.