|
New
York Times
March
3, 2002
UPGRADING
SECURITY IN APARTMENTS SECURITY
experts say that many co- op and condominium boards now quietly
re-evaluating their buildings' security needs. "Since 9/11 we've
had a tremendous increase in calls to conduct background
investigations on new employees and new people moving into
buildings," said Michael G. Kessler, chief executive of Kessler
International, a Manhattan-based security consulting firm. "And a
number of companies we deal with in the business of installing alarms
and surveillance cameras have seen their business skyrocket as
well."
Mr. Kessler said that while every building has unique
strengths and weaknesses, there are a few broad categories to be
examined. The most obvious, he said, is the physical security of the
building itself. Basically, Mr. Kessler said, this means preventing
unauthorized individuals from gaining access to the building and to
apartments within it.
Another critical element, he said, is to make sure that those who
are authorized to be in the building do not themselves pose a threat
to residents. That, Mr. Kessler said, can be accomplished by
conducting background checks on employees and perhaps even new
residents.
And a third element of a safety and security plan — emergency
management and evacuation planning — has less to do with preventing
problems than with responding to those that occur.
"Everyone seems to be a little more vigilant now," Mr.
Kessler said. "And we're seeing a move on the residential side to
security strategies that have been in place in commercial buildings
for years."
Michael Cherkasky, president and chief executive of Kroll Inc., a
Manhattan-based international security firm, said that for a co-op or
condominium board to assess a building's needs, it must first
determine the building's security profile. "Some buildings have
higher security profiles than others," he said, explaining that
buildings that are close to potential targets of terrorism —
government offices, foreign consulates, and even, perhaps, churches
and synagogues — will have higher security profiles than buildings
that are not near such targets.
And people who live or work in a building can have an impact on the
building's security profile. "You can have one tenant in the
building whose presence changes the profile of the entire
building," Mr. Cherkasky said, pointing out that government
officials, diplomats, corporate executives and certain celebrities can
increase the need for tighter security in a building.
"So the first thing a co-op or condominium board should do is
get an assessment of the types of risks their particular building is
exposed to," he said.
Dave Aggleton, president of Aggleton & Associates, a
Manhattan-based security consulting company, agreed.
"It is imperative for boards and building owners to analyze
security needs before developing security solutions," Mr.
Aggleton said. "Most residential buildings do not have
particularly high levels of security. But the events of Sept. 11 have
provided a good opportunity for people to reassess what their security
needs really are."
Mr. Aggleton, who is also vice president of the International
Association of Professional Security Consultants, a trade organization
based in Buena Vista, Calif., said that the most obvious place to
start with a physical security plan is at the front door.
"You can always lock the front door," he said. "But
keys are very easily duplicated."
An alternative to keyed locks on the exterior front door — or an
interior vestibule door — is the magnetic card-type device used in
many hotels. "The most common card reader now is the proximity
reader," he said, explaining that instead of requiring a card to
be slid into a slot, a proximity reader will unlock the door when the
card is held close to the reader's electronic sensor. Even those
devices, however, are not foolproof. "The card reader is only
checking the card, not the person who is using it," Mr. Aggleton
said.
In fact, he said, the most secure entry systems available today are
"biometric access control systems." Such systems, Mr.
Aggleton said, recognize some unique feature about the person
attempting to gain access. "There are a number of different types
of biometric devices," he said. "Some will do a retinal eye
scan, some will scan the iris, some will recognize a fingerprint and
some will do hand geometry checking."
Andsome biometric devices are not nearly as expensive as one might
think, he said. Available for as little as $900, "fingerprint
readers are only about three times the price of a regular card
reader," he said. And while additional equipment is needed to
install an entire system — including a controller panel, a computer,
software and an electric locking mechanism on the door — it is
possible to install a state-of-the-art biometric access control system
in a building for less than $10,000.
Mr. Aggleton added that all potential points of access to a
building need to be secured. For example, he said, if a building has a
service entrance, it might be wise to have an electric locking device
on the door that can be opened by a building employee in the lobby who
is monitoring the service entrance over a closed circuit television
camera. It is also possible to install cameras in the vestibule that
make it possible for occupants to see who is calling on them without
leaving their apartments.
Gregory J. Carlson, executive director of the Federation of New
York Housing Cooperatives and Condominiums, said that one way for a
building to increase security without installing expensive electronics
is to have a human being stationed in the lobby. In some buildings,
Mr. Carlson said, a doorman might be sufficient. In others, the
doorman could be supplemented with a uniformed security guard.
"You can have a guard on duty for one shift, two shifts, or on a
24-hour basis," he said. "You just tailor the contract to
meet the needs of the building."
Security guards, who usually cost $10 to $15 an hour, can be useful
even in buildings with a doorman. "You can use the security guard
as an escort for when people come into the building to look at
apartments for sale," Mr. Carlson said, adding that in large
buildings or buildings with parking garages, additional guards can
patrol different parts of the building or the garage. "In the
building where I live, we have an extra guard who comes in at night
just to watch the garage," he said.
Mr. Kessler of Kessler International said that even when access to a
building is tightly controlled, it is still necessary to ensure that
those who have been granted access do not themselves pose a security
risk.
"A lot of boards are asking us to do background checks of new
employees and people moving into the building," Mr. Kessler said,
explaining that such investigations typically involve following up on
information about the individual's past that has been provided by the
individual. "We will go out and interview people they've worked
for and speak to people in places where they've lived," he said.
In some cases, Mr. Kessler added, public records will be checked to
determine if a prospective employee or tenant-shareholder has a record
of any criminal convictions. "There are different levels of
background checks you can do," he said, adding that such an
investigation can range from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars.
A critical element of any building security plan is to have a plan
in place in the event an emergency occurs. Daniel J. Satoma, a
Manhattan lawyer who specializes in emergency management, said that
since the safety of building residents is ultimately the
responsibility of the building owner — whether that owner is an
individual or a corporation — it is critical for owners and co-op
and condominium boards to make sure that there is an emergency
evacuation plan in place.
"Tenants should understand exactly how they should be exiting
the building," Mr. Satoma said. "They should know where the
emergency exits are located, they should know that some of the
building systems may not be working, and they should know where to go
upon exiting the building."
In addition, Mr. Satoma said, a building's management should
determine whether there are any tenants in the building who will
require assistance getting out and then make plans for providing such
assistance.
"Communication between residents and building management is
critical," he said. "Owners and boards who understand that
will have an opportunity to create a safer and more secure environment
for the people in their buildings."
|